Before the second wave of Covid-19 started in Nepal, the Tikapur Hospital in Kailali procured seven ventilators. But, with a few health workers and doctors available to operate the ventilators and provide critical care, many of those infected who came to the hospital lost their lives. As of May 2021, 46 people died at the hospital due to the disease.
“We had the equipment but couldn’t find the doctors to operate them. Many couldn’t be saved due to a lack of human resources to operate ventilators,” says Deepak Rawal, the hospital chairman.
The hospital has provisions for eight specialist doctors, including anesthesiologists, and four medical officers (appointed by the government), but all the positions have remained vacant for years. Despite repeatedly issuing notices to appoint doctors on a contract basis, the hospital has not received any application. “We appealed to the federal and the provincial governments, as we couldn’t find a doctor. But, we got nothing but assurances,” says Rawal.
The Tikapur Hospital is currently run by doctors hired on contracts with the help of donor organisations and those recruited under two-year scholarship programmes, various other schemes such as the safe motherhood programme, and campaigns run by the local government. Medical Superintendent Rem Kumar Rai says, “Health care services can’t be run in a sustainable and reliable manner if they are run by doctors working under scholarship programmes or those on contract.”
The condition of Tikapur Hospital is a reality common to government and community hospitals across the country. The auditor general’s annual reports point out that a significant number of positions to be filled by doctors have remained vacant in government hospitals across the country for years.
The vacancies, which are to be filled by the Public Service Commission, have not been filled for the last four years because the Ministry of Health, the body that appoints doctors at state-run hospitals, has been reluctant under the excuse that the adjustment of doctors at the federal and local levels after the country adopted federalism is yet to be completed.
Some hospitals have hired doctors at their own expense, but the burden of increased costs has been transferred to patients. A United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) and the European Union study on the cost of healthcare released in June states that the average Nepali family bears more than 50 per cent of the cost of treatment from their own pocket. Former director-general of the Department of Health Services, Sushil Nath Pyakurel, says, “This means that the people are not being treated with the money paid by taxpayers.”
Reaching the hospital on time doesn’t save lives
As of September 30, 2021, 11,123 people have lost their lives due to Covid-19 across the country. A news report based on analysis of the Covid-19 death data till mid-June had found that 92 per cent died at hospitals. Only five per cent lost their lives at home, while less than one per cent lost their lives on the way to hospitals and at isolation centres, according to the report published on the online news portal, Nepal Live, in collaboration with the Centre for Data Journalism (CDJN).
Among the many reasons behind the death of the infected who reach the hospital on time is the lack of adequate infrastructure and equipment, such as intensive care units and ventilators. A lack of specialist doctors is another major problem faced by hospitals. Dr Subash Acharya, in charge of the intensive care unit at the TU Teaching Hospital, says, “The number of ICUs and ventilators is negligible compared to the population we serve, and the human resources available is even less.”
According to the Ministry of Health, 70 per cent of the 793 positions created for specialist doctors at government hospitals across the country are currently vacant. Although 890 posts have been allocated for doctors with a graduation degree in medical education (MBBS), 25 per cent of the posts are vacant. A total of 15 per cent of those MBBS doctors on the job are on study leave.
It is clear from the figures that at a time when the number of positions allocated is already low, only half of the doctors are providing services. The auditor general’s annual report also mentions that patients admitted to government hospitals need to be referred elsewhere due to the non-filling of vacancies in approved posts, and this has affected the delivery of services.
Mass exodus amid a shortage of doctors
Even during this shortage of doctors, it has been four years since the Public Service Commission issued vacancy calls to fill existing posts. Ever since a vacancy for 100 doctors was announced in 2017, not a single permanent doctor has been inducted into government service.
Even the doctors who have received scholarships to complete their medical education have gone abroad, as the hiring process of the health workers is halted. Doctors who enter government service receive the opportunity to complete their MD/MS degrees through government scholarships, and for this reason, many doctors aspire to work for government hospitals. But, with the Public Service Commission not conducting exams, they too have decided to go abroad.
A report by the Centre for Investigative Journalism, Nepal, published in January 2020, revealed more than 50 per cent of doctors who studied on government scholarships have gone abroad. The number of doctors going abroad had been high following the Public Service Commission’s reluctance to conduct exams; the trend has intensified further amid the Covid-19 pandemic. “The number of specialist doctors going abroad has increased recently due to the lack of the option to join the public service,” says Dr Kirtipal Subedi, the general secretary at the Government Doctors’ Association of Nepal (GODAN).
Countries including the United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom offer attractive packages, including an opportunity to complete higher education, to doctors who have studied on government scholarships. It is estimated that in the last four years, about 400 doctors have gone to the United States alone to pursue their MD degrees. The number of doctors going to Canada and the United Kingdom is also significant.
Kedar Bhakta Mathema, the chairman of the High-Level Task Force on National Medical Education Policy 2015, says, if doctors who studied on scholarship continue to go abroad the way they are now, the government’s investment in education is a waste of money. “The reason the doctors get a scholarship is that they are to stay in the country to serve the people,” he says.
Along with the delay in filling government posts, the low salary on offer is also another reason doctors are going abroad. The salary paid by a private hospital to a new doctor is usually Rs 30,000 to 40,000, which pales in comparison to what a doctor can make abroad.
The maze called ‘adjustment’
Since the country adopted federalism, around 26,000 health workers, including 242 specialist doctors and 665 medical officers at the federal, provincial, and local levels have been adjusted. Among them, 82 per cent (22,103) health workers serve at the local level, 8.6 per cent (2,308 people) at the provincial level, and 8 per cent (2,151 people) at the federal level.
However, the Ministry of Health has remained silent on the recruitment of doctors, saying that it still needs to manage the grievances of serving doctors.
The ministry spokesperson Dr Krishna Prasad Poudel admits the recruitment of doctors has not resumed since the adjustment process began. “Positions have remained vacant and this has affected health services,” he says.
When asked about the reason for the suspension of recruitment, the then joint-secretary of the Administration Division, Damodar Regmi, says he had requested the Public Service Commission not to recruit new doctors as he had yet to address grievances presented by serving doctors about their adjustment. “But, we will announce vacancies for around 150 doctors by mid-September after around 5 per cent of the doctors working at the federal level retire from service,” he adds.
However, there are more health workers at the provincial and local levels compared to that at the federal level. And, not all the provincial public service commissions are ready to recruit doctors. Even during the first wave of the Covid-19 pandemic, the federal government could not send doctors to the worst-hit areas as people died in remote parts of the country. And, the main reason this happened was that the recruitment of health workers remained halted.
Some local and provincial governments that faced difficulties treating Covid-19 patients had also appealed to the provincial public service commissions to recruit doctors. The public service commission in Lumbini in September 2020 and the Bagmati province in November issued vacancies for various posts. However, the federal government, which has shown no interest in hiring health workers, wrote to the commissions not to go ahead with the recruitment, as the adjustment of staffers had not been completed. Health Secretary Laxman Aryal wrote to all the provincial public service commissions in November 2020 to halt the recruitment of doctors. Baburam Gautam, a member of the Lumbini Public Service Commission, says, “During the Covid-19 pandemic, the health ministry neither sent doctors to the provinces nor allowed them to recruit doctors on their own.”
However, the Lumbini and Bagmati commissions ignored the ministry’s letter. The final results of exams conducted for nurses, health assistants, and lab technicians are yet to be published in Bagmati. The chairman of the commission in the province, Suresh Man Shrestha, says vacancies for 26 posts, including that for nine medical officers, will be issued with priority. Meanwhile, the vacancy call issued by the Lumbini Provincial Public Service Commission last September for 49 medical officers, seven nursing officers, five physiotherapists, and five medical lab officers has been on hold following a writ petition filed at the Supreme Court.
The Public Service Commission of Province 2 has issued a call in the last week of June, but it will still take months to appoint new doctors.
While no new doctors have been hired in the last four years, four secretaries have assumed office at the Ministry of Health: Dr Pushpa Chaudhary, Ram Prasad Thapaliya, Yadav Prasad Koirala, and Laxman Aryal. Dr Roshan Pokharel is currently the secretary.
Meanwhile, Bhanu Bhakta Dhakal, Hridayesh Tripathi, Sher Bahadur Tamang, and Krishna Gopal Shrestha have taken charge as the minister for health at different times during the course of the pandemic. Umesh Shrestha is now the minister of state for health. However, no one has tried to fill the vacant positions for doctors.
When inquired about why the recruitment of human resources had been stopped for four years, Dr Gunaraj Lohani, the chief of the Policy, Planning and Monitoring Division at the ministry, says, “The exams for the appointment of health workers has been halted as there is a vacancy in the Public Service Commission itself.”
Despite Lohani’s claim, the Ministry of Health has not sought the appointment of doctors. On top of that, positions at the commission became vacant only a short time ago. Devi Prasad Subedi, the information officer of the commission, says, “The Ministry of Health hasn’t asked us to recruit doctors in the last five years.”
Gautam, a member of the Lumbini Provincial Public Service Commission, says, “Many local and provincial hospitals tried to appoint doctors on contract during the pandemic, but no applications were received. If we had issued a call for permanent appointment, things would have been different, but the federal government hasn’t done so.”
General Secretary of Government Doctors Association of Nepal (GODAN) Dr Kirtipal Subedi said the problem surfaced after the management of the health workers were delegated to three levels of government.
“The Health Service Act 1991 classified health services as technical services. Now, after the adjustment, the chain of command from the bottom to the top has been broken. That is why the federal government has been unable to send doctors to the area where the epidemic spread,” says Dr Sushil Nath Pyakurel, former director-general at the Department of Health Services, adding that the government’s decision to merge the health service with the general civil service reminds him of the Panchayat period.
The negative role played by the federal government in the recruitment and management of human resources in health services is not limited to this. The Federal Civil Service Bill, considered important for the professional development of all government employees, has been stuck in Parliament for two and a half years. Due to the stalemate, the provinces have been unable to enact laws related to the career development of health workers. In the absence of provincial laws, it is unclear how doctors appointed at the local level will fare in the future.
60 per cent posts vacant in Province 2
The worst is taking place in Province 2, which lags in all aspects of education and health in the Human Development Index. In every review meeting held at the office of the chief minister or the ministries, it is reported that about 60 per cent of health workers’ posts in the province are vacant.
An example of how poor the province’s healthcare is can be seen at the district hospital in Malangawa, Sarlahi. The hospital has a ventilator, but it does not have a specialist doctor to operate it. The contract to purchase equipment worth Rs 30 million to build infrastructure for the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) is in the final stage, but no paediatrician is being sought.
The posts of all the eight specialist doctors and three of five medical officers at the hospital have been vacant for years. Five fresh MBBS doctors recruited under a provision of mandatory two-year services for scholarships are running the hospital.
Nawal Kishor Jha, who became the medical superintendent of the Malangwa Hospital in April after heading the health division at the Ministry of Social Development of Province 2, says, “We have asked the Public Service Commission to recruit doctors, but it hasn’t issued any vacancy announcements.”
The story of Siraha, Gaur and Janakpur hospitals is no different than that of Sarlahi. Acting medical superintendent of the Siraha Hospital, Dr Nagendra Yadav, is the only specialist doctor of the hospital, which has provision for 10 specialist doctors. Admitting that, the hospital, which was upgraded from 15 to 50 beds five years ago, has not written to the Public Service Commission (the provincial commission after 2018). Dr Yadav says, “The commission had verbally asked us about the doctors, but didn’t seek anything in writing.”
Nineteen of the 25 specialist doctors’ positions at the Janakpur Hospital are vacant. The Province 2 Public Service Commission issued vacancy calls for seven specialist doctors in May. Then, in July, it issued calls for 17 specialist doctors and two medical officers. According to the commission spokesperson Gangesh Gunjan Jha, it is yet to announce vacancies for other health workers including nurses.
Hospitals should send their requirements for health workers to the Public Service Commission through the Ministry of Social Affairs, which forwards the request to the Chief Minister’s Office. The CM’s Office then communicates with the Public Service Commission. So the hospitals themselves do not seek to hire doctors or if they do, their requests get stuck at the Ministry of Social Development or the Chief Minister’s Office. Efforts to know how many healthcare-related recruitment requests have been sent to the federal and provincial public service commissions in the last four years were in vain. Multiple efforts to get answers from Yam Prasad Bhusal, the spokesperson for the Chief Minister’s Office; Bishnuraj Dhakal, Bhusal’s superior; and Chief Secretary Gokarna Mani Duwadi did not turn out to be fruitful.
Government’s priority: Populist programmes and buildings
In the 15 months since the outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic, health workers have found themselves in dire straits. Even in such a situation, the appointment of health workers has not been prioritised by the government. The federal budget for the previous fiscal year, which coincided with the pandemic, and this year’s budget for the second wave of the disease do not even mention the appointment of permanent doctors.
Similarly, no plan or package has been brought to send doctors living in urban areas to the remote ones. So much so that last year, doctors and health workers on the frontline were frustrated by the untimely payment of 100 per cent of their basic pay. Later, authorities said a risk allowance would be given only to those doctors working between April to July 2020. However, the allowance was not paid on time. Dr Ajit Mallik had to sit in for 28 days just to receive the incentive allowance for working for four months in the treatment of Covid-19 patients at the TU Teaching Hospital, Maharajgunj.
During the second wave of infections, the risk allowance for doctors and health workers involved in the treatment by taking more risks was slashed. In his address to the nation on May 3, four days after a lockdown was announced due to the second wave, the then Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli had reduced the 100 per cent incentive allowance to 50 per cent from the previous year.
The then Finance Minister Bishnu Prasad Poudel increased the old age allowance by Rs 1,000. While most of the senior citizens were losing their lives due to Covid-19 and lack of treatment, the government has allocated Rs 16.90 billion on old-age allowances for the current fiscal year. However, just one-third of the expenditure (Rs 5.63 billion) could have been used to pay double the number of existing specialist doctors and physicians, but also an additional 10,000 nurses.
Economist Keshav Acharya says, “The government could have created new postings for doctors instead of deciding to increase its recurring financial burden, but it got stuck with cheap popularity.”
Four years ago, the Pushpa Kamal Dahal-led government launched the Health Infrastructure Standards and Integrated Health Infrastructure Development Project. Officials had spelt out the number of health institutions to be built under the three tiers of government by 2024 and the human resources needed to run the facilities.
The plan was to build 3,329 health posts, 733 primary hospitals, 15 second-tier hospitals, 15 tertiary hospitals, eight central speciality hospitals, and eight teaching hospitals during the period. Similarly, the number of medical officers would be increased from 1,367 to 6,300, the number of specialist doctors from 671 to 3,300, and the number of nurses to 30,000.
According to the same plan, then Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli laid the foundation stone of 396 hospitals (five to 15 beds) at each local unit on December 20, 2020. Prime Minister Oli, who was eager to spend nearly Rs 58 billion on the buildings, was not sensitive about recruiting the necessary health workers to run these facilities.
Gagan Thapa, the then health minister of the Dahal-led government who led the formulation of both the plans, says, “The government cherry-picked the plan to build hospitals and procure equipment. But, for some unknown reason, it didn’t launch any programme to recruit health workers who would attend to the sick.”
Dr Pyakurel, the chief health specialist at the Ministry of Health, says, “Two to three doctors are essential in all of the 753 local level hospitals. In that sense, at least 1,500 to 2,000 new doctors are needed. However, the government hasn’t given the recruitment of health workers a thought.”
The first and the second wave of Covid-19 serve a lesson that equipment, including ventilators, can be procured, but essential human resources cannot be mobilized on short notice. Former Health Minister Thapa says, “We have repeatedly urged the leaders through Parliament to make plans and programmes for healthcare professionals, but no one understands or doesn’t want to understand the situation.”
According to economist Keshav Acharya, the collusion between the government’s leadership, high-level administrators, and contractors and suppliers are the reason authorities focused on equipment and buildings rather than doctors and nurses. Former member of the Nepal Medical Council, Dr Sushil Koirala, on the other hand, alleges that the construction of the hospital building was prioritised as the appointment of doctors does not entail any additional benefits. He says, “If we want to appoint as many doctors and nurses as we need right now, we have to manage the human resources efficiently and also provide the necessary equipment. Health officials are not aware of this.”