+

Two decades after peace deal, impunity still undermines rule of law, states Advocacy Forum

advocay forum

Kathmandu, November 22

Twenty years after Nepal signed the Comprehensive Peace Agreement (CPA), successive governments have failed to uphold the rule of law and hold perpetrators accountable for serious human rights violations, Advocacy Forum-Nepal said.

In a press statement issued on Friday, the rights organisation released a new report titled “Closing the Impunity Gap: Rule of Law and Accountability in Nepal – Twenty Years Since the Comprehensive Peace Agreement”. The report says entrenched impunity, political interference and weak institutions continue to deny justice to victims and their families.

Drawing on two decades of monitoring and legal advocacy, the report examines emblematic cases of enforced disappearances, extrajudicial killings, torture, rape and excessive use of force. The cases span the period before, during and after the 1996–2006 armed conflict. It identifies systemic failures in the police, the prosecution service, the judiciary and transitional justice mechanisms. Even when investigations or prosecutions took place, it says, perpetrators often escaped punishment, received lenient sentences or remained beyond the authorities’ reach.

“The promise of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement was not simply to end the armed conflict. It was to build a country where human rights are respected, institutions are independent, and nobody is above the law,” the organisation said. “Twenty years later, that promise remains largely unfulfilled.”

No case resolved by transitional justice bodies

The report says the transitional justice process has failed to deliver truth and justice. Neither the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) nor the Commission for the Investigation of Enforced Disappeared Persons (CIEDP) has concluded an investigation in a single case since the original legislation was adopted in 2014. The CIEDP has received about 1,300 complaints of enforced disappearance but has not referred any case for further investigation or prosecution.

Among the emblematic cases it examines are the torture and death of 15-year-old Maina Sunuwar in army custody, the enforced disappearance and killing of Hari Prasad Bolakhe, the killing of journalist Dekendra Thapa, and the unresolved disappearance and killing of Arjun Lama.

The report also covers more recent cases, including the deaths of prisoners Binod Tolangi and Aakash Balhami in Sankhuwasabha District Prison in 2023. Five police personnel, two prison guards and eight inmates were convicted in June 2026, but the organisation says such outcomes remain exceptional.

It also flags the prevalence of torture in Child Reform Homes. In a survey of 1,370 juveniles, 328 children (24 percent) reported being tortured. Advocacy Forum-Nepal says it is not aware of any of these cases reaching court.

Call for accountability over Gen Z protest killings

The report gives particular attention to the September 2025 Gen Z protests. It says at least 76 people were killed and more than 2,300 injured in shootings by the Nepal Police and the Armed Police Force. The vast majority of protesters were unarmed, it says, and some of those killed were schoolchildren.

The Karki Commission and the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) have both recommended action against politicians, senior officials and police personnel over the excessive use of force. At the time of writing, however, no prosecutions had been actively initiated, the report says. Meanwhile, 445 cases are proceeding against 1,778 Gen Z protesters.

“The state cannot apply the law selectively,” the organisation said. “Accountability must extend to those who give orders, those who carry them out, and those who obstruct investigations.”

Structural weaknesses and demands

The report lists several weaknesses in the criminal justice system. These include police refusal to register First Information Reports (FIRs), the 35-day limitation period for filing complaints in certain cases, political interference in investigations and judicial appointments, and non-implementation of court orders. It also cites weak victim and witness protection, non-implementation of NHRC recommendations, and the absence of legal provisions on command responsibility.

Advocacy Forum-Nepal has urged the government to create a National Police Commission, an independent police complaints authority and a police inspectorate, and to establish an independent public prosecutor’s office separate from the government’s legal advisory function. It has also called for amending the TRC Act through an inclusive process so that serious violations and international crimes are not subject to amnesty.

To remove barriers to justice, the organisation has asked the government to abolish the 35-day limitation period, allow FIRs to be registered at any police station, and criminalise the refusal to register complaints on grave violations. It has further demanded command responsibility for senior officials and commanders, along with implementation of NHRC recommendations within fixed timeframes and stronger witness protection.

On the Gen Z protests, it has urged prompt implementation of the Karki Commission and NHRC recommendations. It has also called on the government to make public the reports of the Mallik, Rayamajhi and Lal Commissions.

The report says the current government’s stated commitments to good governance and ending political patronage offer an opportunity for reform. However, it says these will remain inadequate unless translated into concrete institutional changes that guarantee independent investigations and prosecutions.

“The real measure of Nepal’s peace process cannot be simply the absence of armed conflict,” the organisation said. “It must be whether people can live free from fear, whether victims can obtain justice, and whether the law applies equally to everyone.”

The organisation has also urged the government to publish an action plan with clear timelines for implementing the outstanding commitments on human rights, accountability and the rule of law.

React to this post

Conversation

New Old Popular

Related News