
Kathmandu, November 17
The Pancheshwar Multipurpose Project, which has remained stalled for three decades since the signing of the Mahakali Treaty, is unlikely to make any significant progress during Prime Minister Balendra Shah’s upcoming visit to India.
Officials at Nepal’s Energy and Foreign Ministries say both sides are positive about including the project on the agenda of Shah’s India visit. However, they see little possibility of a concrete breakthrough.
The 1996 Mahakali Treaty between Nepal and India provides for the construction of the Pancheshwar Multipurpose Project, with both countries sharing its overall benefits.
Yet, three decades after the treaty was signed, the two countries have not reached an agreement on the project’s detailed project report (DPR).
Both sides have conducted separate studies, and a joint draft DPR has also been prepared. However, disagreements over the assessment of project benefits, investment sharing and downstream benefits have prevented technical teams and experts from finalising it.
“Officials from both Nepal and India have completed the work that needs to be done at the administrative level. If the project is genuinely to move forward, there must be an agreement at the political level,” a senior government source said. “Once there is political agreement, the DPR can be finalised immediately.”
Such political consensus has remained elusive. Although Nepal is expected to push for an agreement during Shah’s visit, India has reportedly conveyed that it can move towards a formal agreement only after broader political consensus is reached within Nepal.
“There is a deep political divide in Nepal over this project. India’s position is that the government should first secure a minimum level of consensus among all political parties before reaching an agreement,” the source told Onlinekhabar.
Political opposition in both countries
The Pancheshwar project envisages a high dam on the Mahakali River, known as the Sharda in India. The proposed 311-metre dam has faced opposition in India, particularly in Uttarakhand, over concerns about large-scale land submergence, displacement and environmental damage.
Regional political parties and environmental activists in Uttarakhand have repeatedly protested against the project. Demonstrations were held in Dehradun and several other cities in the state, particularly in 2010 and 2017.
Concerns include the displacement of more than 30,000 people in Uttarakhand and the submergence of large areas on both sides of the border. These objections have also made it difficult for India to advance the project, according to government sources.
“India may be shifting its own difficulties towards Nepal by raising the issue of broader political consensus. There have been sharp political disagreements in Nepal since the Mahakali Treaty was signed. Both sides may be reluctant to move ahead because an agreement could invite opposition in their respective countries,” the source said.
The source added that there were no insurmountable technical issues that could not be resolved if the two countries reached an agreement at the highest political level.
“Once there is political consensus, a meeting of the team of experts can be convened immediately to move the project forward,” the source said.
Disagreement over benefits and investment

Nepal and India do not have a major disagreement over sharing the electricity generated by the project equally. The main differences concern the valuation of benefits from irrigation and flood control, which have made it difficult to agree on how much each country should invest.
Nepal has proposed bearing 30 per cent of the project cost, with India covering the remaining 70 per cent. India has agreed in principle to bear 65 per cent, but maintains that Nepal should contribute 35 per cent.
Under the Mahakali Treaty, the cost of the project should be shared in proportion to the overall benefits received by each country, including electricity, irrigation and flood control.
India is expected to receive substantial irrigation benefits, covering around 240,000 hectares, as well as significant flood-control benefits. Nepal argues that this justifies a larger share of the investment being borne by India.
The issue of existing water rights has further complicated negotiations.
India maintains that the project must not reduce its existing rights to water used through the Lower Sharda Barrage, located 163 kilometres downstream from the Sharda Barrage at Banbasa. The Lower Sharda Barrage is entirely within Indian territory.
Nepal, however, argues that India also uses water from the Karnali River, known as the Ghaghara in India, through the Lower Sharda Barrage and therefore cannot claim all the water used there as part of its existing rights over the Mahakali.
Nepal’s position is that the Mahakali is a shared river and its water should be divided equally. It also maintains that India should pay for any water it uses beyond its share.
Former energy secretary Chiranjibi Chataut says the failure to agree on certain provisions of the DPR remains one of the project’s main obstacles.
After Nepal and India conducted separate studies, a joint team prepared a draft DPR. However, technical issues and disagreements over the distribution of benefits prevented its finalisation, he said.
A team of experts led by the secretary of Nepal’s Water and Energy Commission Secretariat and the head of India’s Central Water Commission has been formed to finalise the DPR. The team has held four or five meetings but has yet to reach a conclusion.
“The Mahakali Treaty states that investment should be proportional to the benefits received. The project has three major benefits — energy, irrigation and flood control. There is no disagreement over sharing electricity equally, but India receives greater benefits from irrigation and flood control,” Chataut said.
He added that sufficient studies and analyses had already been conducted on the distribution of benefits, and a firm agreement on their respective shares could help the project move forward quickly.
Political agreement needed to break the deadlock
According to Chataut, a project of the scale of Pancheshwar requires clear political agreement alongside technical discussions.
With technical teams having completed much of their studies and analysis, political leaders must now provide a clear framework for sharing benefits and investment, he said.
“Political leadership is the main driving force behind taking forward projects of this scale. If the political level establishes a clear understanding and roadmap, technical teams and the bureaucracy can prepare the necessary documents and analysis accordingly,” Chataut said.
He noted that the process had repeatedly stalled in the past despite the two sides coming close to an agreement.
He believes the current situation presents an opportunity to reach a political understanding, finalise the DPR and establish an investment model.
The government has allocated Rs 12 million in the current fiscal year’s budget (2083/84) for the Pancheshwar Development Authority and work related to the DPR. However, the allocation alone is unlikely to move the project forward without agreement on the substantial construction costs, benefit-sharing arrangements and water-use rights.
If Shah’s India visit produces a political understanding on how to proceed with Pancheshwar, it could provide an opening to revive a process that has remained stalled for three decades.
Equal electricity sharing, but investment based on overall benefits
Article 3 of the Mahakali Treaty, which was signed on February 12, 1996, contains provisions for the Pancheshwar Multipurpose Project. It envisages the joint development and operation of the project to achieve the integrated development of the Mahakali River.
The treaty provides for equal sharing of the total electricity generated by the project. It envisages powerhouses of equal capacity on both sides of the river, operated as an integrated system.
However, the treaty does not require the two countries to share construction costs equally. Instead, costs must be determined in proportion to the overall benefits each country receives.
This includes benefits from hydropower generation, irrigation and flood control. Although Nepal and India will receive equal shares of electricity, India is expected to gain comparatively more from irrigation and flood control. Both countries broadly acknowledge that India should therefore bear a larger share of the investment.
The estimated project cost, which is based on calculations made decades ago, will also need to be reassessed.
Disputes over water use and existing rights
Water allocation from the Mahakali River is another major issue in the Pancheshwar negotiations, alongside electricity generation and investment sharing.
The Mahakali Treaty states that Nepal’s requirements should receive priority when using the river’s water.
Article 5 provides for priority consideration of Nepal’s water requirements. Article 4 also requires India to provide 10 cubic metres of water per second, equivalent to 350 cusecs, for irrigation in Nepal’s Dodhara-Chandani area.
However, the two countries are still discussing how to account for water rights that each has been exercising before the project is built.
According to the Energy Ministry, the issue remains under discussion as part of the DPR process.
“Nepal has its own position on how water should be allocated, and India has its own. Discussions are also ongoing on the issue of existing use mentioned in the treaty. No final conclusion has been reached so far,” the ministry said.
The lack of agreement on water use has also affected the assessment of the benefits each country will receive and, consequently, the determination of their respective investment shares.
From Modi’s commitment to another stalled process

The Pancheshwar project has repeatedly featured in high-level discussions between Nepal and India. However, political commitments have yet to translate into concrete action.
During Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Nepal in July 2014, an understanding was reached with then Prime Minister Sushil Koirala to move the project forward. The two sides had committed to completing the DPR by November that year.
Addressing Nepal’s Parliament, Modi had also said that work on the project would begin within a year. At the time, he cited a proposed capacity of 5,600 megawatts and said Nepal could benefit substantially from it.
However, the DPR was not completed within the stipulated timeframe.
During then Prime Minister Sher Bahadur Deuba’s visit to India in August 2017, the two sides agreed to finalise the DPR within a month. That deadline also passed without an agreement.
The project has continued to feature in subsequent high-level visits and discussions, but no concrete decision has been made to move it into the construction phase.
The Pancheshwar Development Authority was established in 2014. In 2016, India’s government-owned consultancy company WAPCOS submitted a draft of the integrated DPR. However, the two countries have still not agreed on its final version.
Under the latest integrated DPR proposal, the main Pancheshwar project is expected to generate 4,800 megawatts, while the Rupaligad project would generate another 240 megawatts, taking the total planned capacity to 5,040 megawatts.
Under this proposal, Nepal and India would each receive 2,520 megawatts. Nepal’s share would include 2,400 megawatts from the main project and 120 megawatts from Rupaligad.
As a reservoir-based project, Pancheshwar is expected to generate electricity consistently even during the dry winter months, potentially making a significant contribution to Nepal’s power system.
Better regulation and use of the Mahakali River could also support irrigation in Sudurpaschim. Construction of the project could bring infrastructure development, employment and increased economic activity to Baitadi, Dadeldhura and surrounding areas.
However, the proposed dam and reservoir would submerge areas in both Nepal and India. Resettlement, compensation and environmental impact management would therefore remain important challenges if the project moves ahead.


