+

Government’s ‘one health worker, one institution’ programme stalls amid doctors’ opposition

The government’s plan to keep doctors and health workers dedicated to a single public institution has repeatedly stalled due to inadequate incentives, poor preparation and opposition from medical professionals.

hospital
Emergency ward at Teaching Hospital.

Kathmandu, November 19

An ambitious government programme aimed at improving services at public hospitals by ensuring that doctors and health workers work full-time at a single institution has remained largely unimplemented, despite repeated announcements, approved guidelines and budget allocations.

The ‘One Health Worker, One Health Institution’ programme was designed to ensure that medical professionals employed at government hospitals devote their entire working hours to their respective institutions rather than splitting their time between multiple hospitals and private clinics.

In return, the government was supposed to provide additional financial incentives to compensate for the income doctors would forgo by giving up private practice.

The initiative was considered a potential game changer for public healthcare, where patients often face long waiting periods for treatment and surgery while government-employed doctors work at several private hospitals and clinics.

However, the programme failed to gain momentum due to inadequate funding, opposition from doctors, competing interests in the private healthcare sector, weak government preparation and a lack of continuity across successive governments.

The programme was initially scheduled to begin in 10 government hospitals in July 2021. But it was implemented for only a limited period at Trishuli Hospital in Nuwakot, while the remaining nine hospitals could not put it into practice.

The government subsequently announced plans to prioritise hospitals in remote areas and considered expanding the programme to Bir Hospital, Kanti Children’s Hospital and Paropakar Maternity and Women’s Hospital.

In the fiscal year 2023/24, the government allocated Rs 240 million with the stated objective of expanding the programme to all federal hospitals. However, the initiative failed to deliver the expected results. A review by the Ministry of Health itself found that the programme had not been effectively implemented in most hospitals.

Trishuli Hospital showed what the programme could achieve

Trishuli Hospital was the only one of the 10 selected hospitals to implement the programme, albeit for a limited period.

According to its then chief, Dr Dipendra Pandey, the initiative played an important role in improving the hospital’s service delivery and quality. He says the hospital’s recognition as one of the country’s best hospitals on three occasions was partly attributable to the programme.

“Doctors stopped private practice and devoted their full time to the government hospital. This increased their sense of ownership and responsibility towards the institution,” Pandey says. “Once doctors began treating the public hospital as their own institution, the quality of services also improved.”

Under the programme, doctors were prohibited from practising at private hospitals in exchange for additional financial incentives from the government. This was intended to encourage them to work full-time at public institutions.

Pandey says the arrangement also benefited patients. Previously, patients often struggled to find doctors at outpatient departments and had to visit multiple hospitals to receive treatment. After the programme was introduced, doctors became more accessible at the hospital, allowing patients to receive treatment and follow-up care more consistently.

“The health workers received some financial benefits, but the benefits to patients were many times greater,” he says. “Once doctors stopped going to private hospitals, they began spending more time at the government hospital. They also started focusing on introducing new services, technologies and treatment methods.”

Pandey argues that the programme was not merely about ensuring doctors’ presence at public hospitals. It was also about making proper use of their skills and professional capacity.

Many government-employed doctors currently work at several private hospitals and clinics, often moving from one institution to another after completing their duties. Such doctors are commonly referred to as ‘helmet doctors’.

Pandey says the practice of attending to hundreds of patients in a day while travelling between hospitals leaves doctors with limited time for proper treatment and follow-up. It can also affect their mental well-being and the quality of care they provide.

He attributes the difference between Trishuli Hospital’s experience and the failure elsewhere largely to financial management.

Apart from the government’s additional allowance, doctors at Trishuli Hospital received financial support from the Nick Simons Institute under an agreement with the hospital. The hospital development committee also provided additional funds.

With financial incentives coming from three sources, doctors found it easier to give up private practice and concentrate on the government hospital, Pandey says.

However, even Trishuli Hospital could not sustain the programme after the government stopped providing the necessary budget.

Doctors opposed the programme over pay and benefits

Emergency room at Bir Hospital.

Resistance from doctors and health workers was one of the main obstacles to implementation.

Medical professionals argued that if the government wanted them to work exclusively at public hospitals, it had to ensure adequate salaries, financial incentives and social security.

During consultations on the working procedure, doctors’ organisations had demanded remuneration sufficient to support their families, social security, healthcare facilities for family members, opportunities for further studies and training, and other benefits.

They were dissatisfied that their suggestions had not been incorporated into the guidelines approved by the Cabinet.

As soon as the Health Ministry circulated instructions to implement the programme in the 10 selected hospitals, opposition emerged from different professional organisations.

The Government Doctors’ Association of Nepal and the Nepal Medical Association objected to the provisions and demanded amendments. Doctors at the National Trauma Centre and some other hospitals even warned their administrations that they would resign if the programme was enforced without changes.

An official at the Health Ministry says both government doctors and private hospital operators were opposed to the initiative.

Many department heads, consultants and medical officers working at government hospitals in Kathmandu Valley also provide services at private hospitals and clinics.

According to the ministry official, some government-employed doctors earn additional income through private practice, while others have investments and business interests in private healthcare institutions. Private hospitals also use the names and professional experience of specialists employed at government hospitals to promote their services.

“When the programme is implemented, doctors cannot practise at private hospitals. Government doctors themselves opposed it because of their immediate financial interests,” the official says.

Inadequate incentives and weak government preparation

Dr Gun Raj Lohani, who coordinated the preparation of the programme’s working procedure on behalf of the Health Ministry, identifies opposition from doctors, inadequate financial incentives and poor government preparation as the main reasons for its failure.

He says the programme was not intended to restrict doctors’ professional freedom or deprive them of private practice. Rather, its objective was to create an environment in which doctors could work full-time at one institution, benefiting patients, hospitals and the medical professionals themselves.

“When a doctor has to rush between 10 different places, they may perform surgery at one hospital and then leave for another. If complications arise in a patient they operated on, they may not be able to return immediately,” Lohani says. “A doctor cannot be in two places at the same time. Ultimately, this affects patient care and, in some cases, can even cost lives.”

Lohani says financial incentives were a major sticking point. Although the government wanted doctors to concentrate on a single institution, the additional payments it offered were not sufficient to persuade many of them to give up private practice.

At a time when some doctors were earning up to Rs 1 million through private practice, the government’s offer of Rs 300,000 was considered inadequate, he says.

“At that time, doctors were earning up to Rs 1 million. When the government offered Rs 300,000, they considered it insufficient,” Lohani says. “But earning Rs 1 million does not restore a doctor’s reputation if a patient dies because of inadequate care. This issue should not be viewed solely in terms of financial income.”

He argues that the government should not have abandoned a programme intended to improve public hospital services simply because the proposed incentives were insufficient.

However, Dr Lochan Karki, former president of the Nepal Medical Association, believes the failure was primarily due to the government’s shortcomings rather than doctors’ unwillingness.

According to Karki, there is a significant gap between the salaries and facilities available at government hospitals and the remuneration offered by private institutions.

He says public hospitals often lack the equipment, technology and infrastructure required for doctors to use their skills effectively. In such circumstances, restricting doctors to government institutions without providing adequate facilities and remuneration could not make the programme successful.

“If doctors are expected to treat patients only at government hospitals, the government must provide facilities and remuneration that allow them to support their families,” Karki says. “The government failed to guarantee adequate pay. How can the programme succeed if it prevents health workers from working at private hospitals but does not provide them with proper benefits for working at public institutions?”

Karki says instructions and commitments alone are not enough to retain skilled doctors in government hospitals. The government must also offer competitive remuneration and ensure that hospitals have the equipment, technology and infrastructure needed to provide quality treatment.

He adds that a lack of equipment is itself one of the reasons government doctors seek opportunities at private hospitals.

“Large and essential medical equipment must be made available at government hospitals,” he says.

Ministry acknowledges implementation challenges

The Health Ministry has acknowledged that it failed to adequately address the challenges that emerged during implementation.

Ministry spokesperson Dr Samir Kumar Adhikari says successful implementation requires more than issuing directives to health workers. The government must also boost their morale, provide a suitable working environment and ensure necessary incentives.

He says the Health Ministry alone cannot implement the programme across the entire health system.

Nepal’s healthcare system is divided among federal, provincial and local governments, and not all health institutions fall directly under the Health Ministry. Some institutions and health workers are also affiliated with other ministries and government agencies, requiring coordination among different authorities.

“The morale of health workers is the most important thing. The Health Ministry must facilitate the process and provide incentives,” Adhikari says. “It must take the lead in identifying the difficulties health workers face in carrying out their duties and finding solutions.”

Despite repeated announcements and attempts to expand the initiative, the programme remains largely stalled, leaving its original objective of ensuring full-time medical services at public hospitals unfulfilled.

React to this post

Chaulagain is an Onlinekhabar health correspondent.

More From the Author

Conversation

New Old Popular